There is a topic that I have wished to discuss for some time now and have not gotten around to it yet. I see this as a perfect opportunity to do so. The issue at hand is the perception of Americans and America abroad. As someone who has taken a particular interest in world politics, specifically the influence of American foreign policy at the international level, I have learned that opinions on the subject have been a mixed bag. Some views of America prove to be very cynical, some sympathetic, some grandiose, while others simply outlandish. If I come across someone who holds an opinion, I am genuinely interested to hear what they have to say. I have experienced that Europeans are quicker to differentiate an American from America than many other groups. The fair majority of Europeans that I have met love Americans but hate America. This is a fair assessment and a very difficult statement to refute. The ability of a non-American to make that distinction demonstrates a wisdom and awareness that is lacking stateside. It is great to be able to hear a perspective that is both critical yet sympathetic. When one is talking about a current affair in American politics (or any state's politics for that matter) such as the economy or health care, it is easy to bash the situation from the outside by breaking it down into its most rudimentary form and building a conclusion based on one's individual perspective. The hard part comes in understanding that the situation seldom is ever as clean cut as it would seem. To this end, I must applaud the Europeans that I have met. They may hold contrary views but at least they are humble enough to know that the other side of the coin has some validity as well.
The perception of America by the locals I have come in contact with is very interesting. They absolutely LOVE talking about America and how it's reputation is tarnished because of the actions taken within the better part of the last decade. They talk about how much Bush is disliked and how the war in Iraq is an atrocity. Most examples that they use to demonstrate America's international pariah status is justified but what bothers me is the inability to make that distinction between people and government. Most times when speaking of the issues, "you" is often used to describe actions taken by the US government. "You invaded Iraq for no reason." "You voted for Bush." For certain, "I" didn't invade Iraq nor did "I" vote for Bush. But clarifying those statements is not the point. The point is that the implications of such a mindset causes many Americans to be lumped together into the same ilk which is extremely unfair. Especially in times like these where the degree of citizen representation in government is arguably at a historic low, it is important for the outside world to be able to clearly see the difference between citizen and government; between the people and the decision makers.
Now this is not to say that all Americans see themselves in like terms. There are Americans who truly believe that the Iraq War was justified, that Bush is doing what is right, and that America should always be the international police force. The perfect irony however is the fact that those Americans rarely come in contact with the German, the French, the Grenadian, or the Kajak (those who hold residence in Carriacou). Perhaps, if they did they would see the world in a different way. The Americans who do interact with these people are the ones who are more likely to agree (or at least respect)with a more foreign view point of the US. So when a Kajak tells me that the Iraq War was wrong, he's preaching to the choir. When he says that "I" voted for a horrible president, maybe I should say "No, 'I' didn't vote for him but I have an Uncle that has never left Alabama. You might want to talk to him."
The last thing that I want to say about the whole issue of America and Americans abroad is that I do see some things within myself that are unfortunately indicative of the American culture. I like to think that I am semi-worldly, that I respect the views of others, and that I exercise tolerance whenever confronted with a different set of beliefs and/or culture. But what I have found about myself and about other Americans that I have come in contact with is that we are all stubborn folk. We are people of strong conviction. This can be a good thing and it can also be a bad thing. I feel that this characteristic in intrinsic in our culture and it is something that everyone needs to address individually especially when traveling abroad. Strong principles can be misinterpreted for narrow-mindedness and when encountering a culture that might challenge your principles it is important to tread lightly. Because just like the foreigner that has a damning view of American politics, the American might not fully understand the foreign society that he/she is encountering. I am constantly having a personal debate over this concept, trying to draw the line between strength in conviction and pure stubbornness. It is what I believe to be a key part of the American culture that should be cherished but I can't help but see it also as a hindrance to international tolerance and peace. Just like stated in the beginning, it is important for outsiders to understand these paradoxes about the American culture before they make their final judgements. Some out there do while many people abroad unfortunately do not.
Monday, September 22, 2008
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)